Products
Asiago Cheese
Sold Out
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Asiago - mild, sweet & nutty. Grate onto pasta,...
Beef Tongue
$15.00
Beef Tongue is a delicious delicacy in many cultures. Smoke, pickle, braise or slow cook as a roast. Slice thin for sandwiches, cold beef appetizers or cultural dishes. Create Tacos...
Brisket
$25.00
Cut from the breast so low/slow cooking, smoking, braising. Slow cooking breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a delicious rich & beefy, flavorful result. The grain all goes in...
Broth Bones
$15.00
Beef bones for making stock, soup or broth. Frozen. Use to make bone broth (how to), pho, or sauce. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass...
Butter Roll - 2 lb Salted
$12.00
Salted is Pa or Ohio Produced Amish Butter Roll. 2 lb roll.
Cheeks
$10.00
Boneless alternative to short ribs. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a silky, healthy, rich &...
Chicken Feet
$4.00
Feet from slow-growing Heritage chickens or turkeys raised on pasture. Not scalded or peeled. Frozen.
Chicken Necks
Sold Out
Necks from slow-growing heritage chickens raised on pasture. Great for soup.
Chuck Roast
$22.50
100% grass-fed bone-in chuck roast for pot roast or pulled beef. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen...
Chuck Steak
$13.50
Bone in shoulder steak. Cut thinner than a chuck roast. Slow cook as a small pot roast or pressure cook in InstantPot. Can grill as a flavorful steak if marinated...
Colby - Grass Fed Cheese
Sold Out
100% Grass-fed & made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. No synthetic hormones or antibiotics. 8 oz packages Colby Longhorn is...
Curds
Sold Out
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Curds - Buttery + squeaky = perfect curds for...
Eye of Round Roast
$45.00
Flavorful lean boneless Roast. The grain goes the same direction so it slices well across the grain to for thin sliced rare roast beef. Carve across the grain to maximize tenderness. Roast, braise, slow...
Filet Tenderloin Steak
$9.30
The tenderloin is a tender, little-used muscle in the loin. It has a less intense flavor than other steaks. Pan fry using tallow or butter in a hot skillet for...
Flank Steak
$22.50
Flank steak substitute with deep, rich, robust flavor. Slice thin for stir fry or marinate and grill. Cut across the grain when carving. Popular on the plate or in sandwiches, salads,...
Free Range Chicken Eggs - Dozen
Sold Out
Hand-gathered Heritage chicken eggs from free-range and pasture-raised endangered Partridge Chantecler hens. According to a Mother Earth news study, free-range eggs have: 1/3 less cholesterol 1/4 less saturated fat 2/3...
Free Range Turkey Eggs
Sold Out
Yes, turkeys are hens too! Hand-gathered eggs from endangered Heritage Standard Bronze turkey hens. These delicious rich & creamy jumbo speckled eggs are about 1 1/2 times the size of a...
Gouda Cheese
$8.00
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Gouda - mild cheese. One of the most versatile and...
Ground Dry-Aged Beef
$9.00
Our lean ground beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished on pasture at Old Time Farm. Unlike grocery meats where it’s often difficult to trace the source of ingredients and you...
Hanger Steak
$18.00
Flank steak substitute. Marinate & quickly grill and be sure to cook no more than med-rare. Only 2 per beef so when they are gone, they are gone to our next harvest....
Heart
$20.00
Beef Heart is a delicious delicacy in many cultures. Marinate and grill or braise in a stew. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass Finished on pasture. Vacuum...
Heritage Chicken - Young
$45.00
Heritage breed Partridge Chantecler Chickens are the idyllic "Slow-Growing" old-fashioned chickens like Julia Child cooked with and were found before the industrialization of poultry in the 1950's. Heritage chicken has more flavor...
Heritage Stewing Hen
$35.00
Stew hens are known for their rich chickeny flavor in soups and stews.Cook on the stove, in a crockpot or InstantPot until falling apart. Approximate weights 3-5 lb. Plan to...
Kidney
$4.00
One beef kidney per package, approximately 1 lb each. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass Finished on pasture. Vacuum packed and flash frozen...
Liver
$8.00
Superfood is a potent source vitamins A, B6, B12, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, pantothenic and folic acid, choline, zinc, phosphorus, copper, iron and selenium. Easy to separate portions in flat packages....
Mozzarella Cheese
$8.00
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Mozzarella - Pizza, cut up in a salad, or just...
Old Time Farm e-Gift Card
$10.00
Share the gift of local and keep your holiday dollars in our community with an e-gift card! These cards can only be used for Online purchases for Home Delivery or...
Ox Tail
Sold Out
High collagen cut for low/slow cooking or braising on the stove, in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster. Slow moist cooking breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a healthy,...
Parmesan Cheese
$8.00
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Parmesan - the classic pasta cheese. Grate your own...
Pepper Jack - Grass Fed Cheese
$8.00
100% Grass-fed & made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. No synthetic hormones or antibiotics. 8 oz packages Pepper Jack Add...
Provolone Cheese
$8.00
Local cheese made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. 8 oz packages Provolone - Pizza, sammies, cut up in a salad,...
Ribeye Steak Bone-in
$13.90
Dry-aged bone-in ribeye is our favorite steak! Pan fry using tallow and a hot skillet for the most control or grill. The roast version is used for Prime Rib and the boneless version...
Round Steak
$5.00
Lean & flavorful boneless cut round steak. Use for Beef Stroganoff, Swiss steak, London broil, or stir fry. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass...
Rump Roast
$25.00
Flavorful lean boneless Rump Roast cut. The grain goes the same direction so it slices well across the grain to for thin sliced rare roast beef. Carve across the grain to maximize tenderness. Roast,...
Salmon Burgers
$10.00
Spicy burger ingredients include Wild Alaska Sockeye salmon, fennel, paprika, sea salt, and cayenne pepper. The salmon burgers have no fillers, flour, or gluten. Salmon burgers can be grilled, pan-fried, or...
Shank Soup Bones (Osso Bucco)
$12.00
Crosscut Beef Shank - the same cut used for Osso Bucco. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to...
Sharp White Cheddar - Grass Fed Cheese
$8.00
100% Grass-fed & made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. No synthetic hormones or antibiotics. 8 oz packages Sharp White Cheddar...
Short Ribs
$13.50
Bone-in. Slow cook, braise or Instant-pot to break down the gristle to collagen to provide a rich beefy flavorful result. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed...
