Products
100% Grass Fed Cheese - Middlefield Co-op
$7.00
100% Grass-fed & made right over the border near Ravenna, Ohio. Our Amish neighbors ship milk to this co-op. No synthetic hormones or antibiotics. 8 oz packages Brick is like a...
Beef Cheeks
$9.00
Boneless alternative to short ribs. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a silky, healthy, rich &...
Beef Cheeks - Rose Veal
$11.25
Boneless alternative to short ribs. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a silky, healthy, rich &...
Beef Kidney
$4.00
One beef kidney per package, approximately 1 lb each. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass Finished on pasture. Vacuum packed and flash frozen...
Beef Shank Soup Bones (Osso Bucco)
$11.25
Crosscut Beef Shank - the same cut used for Osso Bucco. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to...
Beef Shank Soup Bones (Osso Bucco) - Rose Veal
$9.00
Crosscut Beef Shank - the same cut used for Osso Bucco. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the gristle to collagen to...
Beef Tongue
$16.00
Beef Tongue is a delicious delicacy in many cultures. Smoke, pickle, braise or slow cook as a roast. Slice thin for sandwiches, cold beef appetizers or cultural dishes. Create Tacos...
Black Eyed Peas Organic 1 lb
$5.00
Black eyed peas are also known as "cow peas". This southern favorite is the key ingredient for "Hoppin' John" which is a traditional food for many for New Years Day...
Bone Broth
Sold Out
Small batch and home-made bone broth from our own Old Time Farm pasture-raised beef, chicken, turkey and Auburn Meadow Farm pork. Great for a cup of soup, to make gravy...
Brisket
Sold Out
Cut from the breast so low/slow cooking, smoking, braising. Slow cooking breaks down the gristle to collagen to provide a delicious rich & beefy, flavorful result. The grain all goes in...
Broth Bones
Sold Out
Beef bones for making stock, soup or broth. Frozen. Use to make bone broth (how to), pho, or sauce. Cattle born & raised on Old Time Farm. 100% Grass Fed & Grass...
Butter Grass Fed Organic
Sold Out
100% Grass Fed Organic butter from Oasis Creamery near Lancaster PA. 8 oz roll.
Butter Roll
$15.00
The butter I have used in our house for years. "As Nature Intended" is the Hartzler Family Dairy philosophy. Pasture raised cows. Locally produced in Wooster Ohio. 100% traceability. No...
Cannellini Beans Organic 1 lb
$5.50
US Grown White Kidney Beans. Eden Foods.
Cheese Curds - Raw Milk
$8.00
Cheese curds are the key ingredient that turn fries with gravy into the famouse comfort food "poutine". These curds are buttery, squeaky and the perfect texture to hold up to...
Chuck Arm Roast
$20.00
100% grass fed bone in chuck arm roast for pot roast or pulled beef. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the...
Chuck Arm Roast - Rose Veal
$18.00
100% grass fed bone in chuck arm roast for pot roast or pulled beef. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the...
Chuck Roast
Sold Out
100% grass fed bone in shoulder chuck roast for pot roast or pulled beef. Low/slow cooking or braising on stove or in Crockpot, InstantPot or covered roaster breaks down the...
Chuck Steak
$10.00
Bone in shoulder steak. Cut thinner than a chuck roast. Slow cook as a small pot roast or pressure cook in InstantPot. More "chew" than our premium steaks but more flavor...
Chuck Steak - Rose Veal
$6.75
Bone in shoulder steak. Cut thinner than a chuck roast. Slow cook as a small pot roast or pressure cook in InstantPot. More "chew" than our premium steaks but more flavor...
Fajita Seasoning
$1.50
Hand mixed in our kitchen using Mountain Rose Organic herbs & spices. All natural - no sugar or thickeners. Fajita (mild taco) seasoning mix for 1 lb of ground or...
Filet Tenderloin Steak
Sold Out
The tenderloin is a tender, little used muscle in the loin. It has a less intense flavor that other steaks. Pan fry using tallow or butter in a hot skillet...
Flank Steak
Sold Out
Flank steak substitute with deep, rich, robust flavor. Slice thin for stir fry or marinate and grill. Cut across the grain when carving. Popular on the plate or in sandwiches, salads,...
Flank Steak - Rose Veal
Sold Out
Flank steak substitute with deep, rich, robust flavor. Slice thin for stir fry or marinate and grill. Cut across the grain when carving. Popular on the plate or in sandwiches, salads,...
Free Range Chicken Eggs
Sold Out
Eggs are Seasonal and the limited production we have in the fall and winter is reserved for our long-term, year-round customers.Sign up for our e-mail list to get the latest news...
Free Range Turkey Eggs
Sold Out
*** PLEASE NOTE: Eggs will not be available to order online until spring. Eggs are Seasonal and the limited production we have in the fall and winter is reserved for our long-term, year...
Frew Mill Fire Raw Milk Cheese
$7.00
Local raw milk farmstead pepper cheese made by Pasture Maid Creamery with the milk from their cows in New Castle PA. Similar in texture and melting to the Meadow Delight colby...
Grass Fed Tallow
$3.00
3 oz grass fed beef tallow (rendered beef suet/fat). Healthy fat for pan-frying steaks, burgers, mushrooms, potatoes or beef stir-fry Just put in a hot pan and pull out with...
Ground Dry-Aged Beef - 1 lb
$10.00
Our flavorful dry-aged lean ground beef is 100% grass-fed and grass finished on pasture at Old Time Farm. Unlike grocery meats where it’s often difficult to trace the source of...
Half Heritage Chicken
Sold Out
Heritage breed Partridge Chantecler Chickens are the idyllic "Slow-Growing" old-fashioned chickens like Julia Child cooked with and were found before the industrialization of poultry in the 1950's. Heritage chicken has more flavor...
Hanger Steak
Sold Out
Flank steak substitute. Marinate & quickly grill and be sure to cook no more than med-rare. Only 2 per beef so when they are gone, they are gone to our next harvest....
Heritage Chicken Feet
$4.00
Feet from slow growing Heritage chickens raised on pasture. Not scalded or peeled. Frozen.
Heritage Chicken Livers
Sold Out
Livers from slow growing chickens raised on pasture. Panfry or bake. Choose COD at checkout and price will be adjusted for actual weight at $8/lb when you receive your order.
Heritage Stewing Hen
Sold Out
Rich chicken flavor, long legs, long thighs and proportional breasts are all hallmarks of slow growing Heritage chicken. Stewing hens are older than our roasting birds when harvested and are best...
Heritage Turkey Breast Cutlets
Sold Out
Turkey breast cutlets from our hatched at home, slow growing heritage turkeys raised on pasture. Grill, panfry or bake. Choose COD at checkout and price will be adjusted for actual...
Homesteader Raw Milk Cheese
$7.00
Local Farmers style raw milk farmstead cheese made by Pasture Maid Creamery with the milk from their cows in New Castle PA. Farmers cheese is a simple, soft mild cheese, similar...
Hulled Barley Organic 1 lb
$2.50
We cook this grain and serve like rice or in barley soup. Hulled barley is more nutritious than pearled barley because it still has the outer husk & bran while...
Italian Sausage Seasoning
$1.50
Hand-mixed in our kitchen using Mountain Rose Organic herbs & spices. All-natural - no sugar or thickeners. Ingredients: Organic fennel seed, organic coriander, organic garlic granules, organic paprika and organic...
Liver
Sold Out
Superfood is a potent source vitamins A, B6, B12, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, pantothenic and folic acid, choline, zinc, phosphorus, copper, iron and selenium. Easy to separate portions in flat packages....
Liver - Calves
Sold Out
Superfood is a potent source vitamins A, B6, B12, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, pantothenic and folic acid, choline, zinc, phosphorus, copper, iron and selenium. Easy to separate portions in flat packages....